Keele neighbourhood development plan - Examiner’s clarification note

This note sets out my initial comments on the submitted plan. It also sets out areas where it would be helpful to have some further clarification. For the avoidance of any doubt, matters of clarification are entirely normal at this early stage of the examination process.

Initial comments

The plan provides a clear vision for the neighbourhood area. It addresses a range of issues which relate closely to its character and appearance.

Points for clarification

I have read the submitted documents and the representations made to the plan. I have also visited the neighbourhood area. I am now able to raise issues for clarification with the Parish Council. I also raise two matters with the Borough Council.

The comments made on the points in this note will be used to assist in the preparation of my report and in recommending any modifications that may be necessary to the plan to ensure that it meets the basic conditions. For clarity, any references in this note to national policy are to the National Planning Policy Framework (December 2024) (NPPF) against which the submitted plan will be examined. 

Questions for the Parish Council

I set out specific policy clarification points below in the order in which they appear in the submitted Plan:

Policy KNP-1

This policy establishes a clear spatial strategy for the neighbourhood area and will focus new development where it is close to the community services in the village.

Is the use of ‘existing built-up areas’ intended to be the same area as the Development Boundary in the recently adopted Local Plan? If so, is there any need for the definition in the policy about infill development for gaps in existing built frontages or brownfield sites?

Policy KNP-2

Is there any evidence or specific justification for the threshold of three homes in the policy?

Has the policy been tested for its commercial viability?

Policy KNP-4

This policy takes a positive approach to community facilities and has regard to Section 8 of the NPPF. In this context:

  • is it reasonable to include the community facilities within the University in the policy?
  • to what extent are those facilities used on a regular basis by the resident community of Keele village?
Policy KNP-5

Many elements of the policy echo national and local policies on character and design. Is the green guidance note the added value of the policy?

Policy KNP-6

In general terms, the policy takes a positive approach to the Conservation Area. 
The supporting text highlights the significance of the estate village. Should this be reflected more closely in the policy itself?

Policy KNP-8

In general terms, this is a good policy which has regard to Section 15 of the NPPF.

In this context, what is the justification for a 20% biodiversity net gain in the fourth part of the policy?

Policy KNP-9

The first part of the policy comments generally about the open landscape setting of Keele Village and maintaining the green gaps separating Keele Village from the surrounding settlements. In this context:

  • what are the surrounding settlements?
  • are the green gaps all the fields shown on Figure 6?

The second part of the policy identifies two areas which the Parish Council considers have particular landscape value as part of the setting of Keele conservation area. Is this approach in addition to the role played by the two areas in the first part of the policy?

In more general terms, is there any added value of the identified areas in the policy beyond the application of green belt policy in the neighbourhood area (as set out in Policy PSD5 of the local plan)?

Policy KNP-10

I looked carefully at the proposed local green spaces (LGSs) during the visit. I note that they are underpinned by the details in the 2025 local green spaces assessment. 

I note the details in the Interpretation of the policy. Given the contents of paragraph 108 of the NPPF, and court cases on how LGS policies should be worded, is there any need for the plan to comment about the five purposes of green belts?

Basic conditions statement (BCS)

The submitted Basic Conditions Statement (April 2026) does not assess the plan against the revised basic conditions introduced in March 2026 or against the local plan which was adopted in July 2026. Whilst I note that the Parish Council sought to remedy this matter in its response to the Regulation 16 consultation process, the approach taken did not allow others to make observations on the document, and the extent to which the plan meets the basic conditions.

In these circumstances, I ask the Parish Council to update and correct the BCS. Once this has been done, I will ask the Borough Council to undertake focused consultation on the revised document.

Matters for the Borough Council

I note that both the environmental assessment screening statement and the habitats regulations screening statement pre-date the adoption of the local plan. In these circumstances, I ask the Borough Council to update these documents.

Representations

Does the parish wish to comment on any of the representations made to the plan?

It would be helpful if the Parish Council responded to the representations from:

  • Persimmon Homes (KE5)
  • Keele University (KE13)
  • Dr Holder (KE20) and
  • the various local residents asking that the coverage of policy KNP-9 is expanded.

The Borough Council makes a series of comments on the policies in the plan and the supporting text. The Parish Council’s responses to these comments would also be helpful.

Protocol for responses

I would be grateful for responses to these questions by 30 November 2026. Please let me know if this timetable may be challenging to achieve. It is intended to maintain the momentum of the examination.

If certain responses are available before others, I am happy to receive the information on a piecemeal basis. Irrespective of how the information is assembled, please could it come to me directly from the Borough Council. In addition, please can all responses make direct reference to the policy or the matter concerned.

Andrew Ashcroft
Independent Examiner

Keele neighbourhood development plan

6 November 2026